MESSAGE
| DATE | 2021-11-29 |
| FROM | Ruben Safir
|
| SUBJECT | Subject: [Hangout - NYLXS] covid education shutdowns
|
School Closures Aren’t Just for Covid Anymore
Remote learning turns out to be an easy fix for other problems—never
mind the huge educational costs.
By Leslie Bienen
Nov. 28, 2021 5:08 pm ET
PHOTO: AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE/GETTY IMAGE
Portland, Ore.
When Reynolds Middle School shut down its classrooms for three weeks, it
wasn’t because of Covid-19 cases. On Nov. 16, parents of students at
school in Troutdale, east of Portland, received a brief email informing
them the school would revert to online learning so that district
officials could develop “safety protocols” and “social-emotional
supports” to deal with disruptive student behavior, including fights.
Reynolds students aren’t alone in being stuck at home again. Thousands
of schools in dozens of districts across the U.S. have taken previously
unscheduled days off or moved back to remote learning for “mental
health” reasons. Other schools have cut back time in school buildings
because of staffing shortages or for “deep cleaning,” a pointless
anti-Covid precaution.
“The shifts in learning methods and isolation caused by COVID-19
closures and quarantines have taken a toll on the well-being of our
students and staff,” Reynolds Superintendent Danna Diaz’s email said.
“We are finding that some students are struggling with the socialization
skills necessary for in-person learning, which is causing disruption in
school for other students.”
It seems perverse to respond to the problems caused by school shutdowns
with more shutdowns—and to send middle schoolers the message that unruly
behavior can get them out of school for three weeks.
As with Covid-19 shutdowns, low-income and minority students likely bear
the brunt of the educational disruption. Reynolds Middle School is in
eastern Multnomah County, and “east county” is shorthand for
underserved, low-income and racially diverse. In October, the high
school in the same district, as a colleague and I reported in these
pages, switched to remote learning for 10 days because of a handful of
Covid cases.
“We started seeing mental health closures around November 1st,” the
Burbio School Tracker reported two weeks later. By Nov. 22, Burbio’s
research team had identified 3,145 school closures for “mental health”
out of a total 8,692 for the school year, the company’s president,
Dennis Roche, said in an email. The large majority were in a handful of
states: Colorado, Michigan, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon and
Virginia. Among them:
• The Detroit Public Schools said the district would go online on
Fridays in December, citing “the need for mental health relief, rising
COVID cases, and time to more thoroughly clean schools.” It later
canceled in-person classes the Monday and Tuesday before Thanksgiving.
The district has 49,000 students, of whom 82% are black, 13% Latino and
78% eligible for subsidized lunch.
• Southfield, Mich., schools are also going remote one day a week,
because of “staffing shortages.” This district is wealthier than nearby
Detroit—only 36% of students need subsidized lunch—and its high-school
graduation rate is 86%. But 94% of the students are black.
• At least a dozen Oregon districts, including Portland Public Schools,
declared Nov. 12 a “professional development day” after juggling staff
shortages all month. With many teachers taking the Friday after Veterans
Day off, it became impossible to staff the buildings sufficiently to
stay open. The head of the Portland Public Schools’ teachers union told
Portland Monthly in early November that teachers wanted a weekly
“asynchronous” day—on which students would be expected to study without
teachers present—so teachers can use the time for planning.
• The Winston-Salem, N.C., district similarly ordered schools closed
Nov. 12: “The ‘assignment’ for staff and students for that day is to
‘take care of themselves,’ ” Superintendent Tricia McManus said. “It
will be a day to focus on the mental health of students and staff by
showing kindness, community, and connection.” It also meant a four-day
weekend, as the schools were already closing for Veterans Day.
Before Covid, school shutdowns happened on snow days and for genuine
emergencies such as natural disasters, school shootings and occasionally
outbreaks of infectious disease like flu, E. coli or, decades ago,
polio. But without remote learning as an option, districts had to resume
class as quickly as possible, or teachers and students would have to
make up missed class days at the end of the year, cutting into summer
vacation. Now school officials have an easy out—but one that comes at a
huge cost to students. States could cut this option off by forcing
districts to meet instructional-hour mandates only with in-person
learning, but few have done so.
Many schools around the country closed during the 1918 influenza
pandemic, but some—including those in New York, Chicago and New Haven,
Conn.—didn’t, although the flu is more infectious in children than
Covid-19 is. In November of that year, New York City Health Commissioner
Royal S. Copeland told the New York Times that open schools were a boon
to public health.
Copeland noted that some 750,000 of the city’s one million public-school
students lived in “unsanitary and crowded” tenements with parents who
“are occupied with the manifold duties involved in keeping the wolf from
the door” and “simply have not the time to give the necessary attention
to the initial symptoms of disease, even if they should have enough
knowledge to recognize and meet them, which they rarely have.” In class,
teachers could give students “the ‘once over’ ” and isolate symptomatic
ones pending a diagnosis.
“Our control of the children in school secured them a degree of safety
that would not have been possible if they had been allowed loose on the
streets,” Copeland said. The article was titled “Epidemic Lessons
Against Next Time.”
A century later, too many schools are failing to make students’ health
and well-being their primary concern. They should revisit the lessons of
1918.
Dr. Bienen is a faculty member at the OHSU-Portland State University
School of Public Health.
WSJ Opinion: Covid Heads Towards Another Winter
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
UP NEXT
WSJ Opinion: Covid Heads Towards Another Winter
WSJ Opinion: Covid Heads Towards Another Winter
Journal Editorial Report: Paul Gigot interviews Dr. Marty Makary. Image:
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
Copyright ©2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8
--
So many immigrant groups have swept through our town
that Brooklyn, like Atlantis, reaches mythological
proportions in the mind of the world - RI Safir 1998
http://www.mrbrklyn.com
DRM is THEFT - We are the STAKEHOLDERS - RI Safir 2002
http://www.nylxs.com - Leadership Development in Free Software
http://www.brooklyn-living.com
Being so tracked is for FARM ANIMALS and extermination camps,
but incompatible with living as a free human being. -RI Safir 2013
_______________________________________________
Hangout mailing list
Hangout-at-nylxs.com
http://lists.mrbrklyn.com/mailman/listinfo/hangout
|
|
